Article,
Modeling abundance using N-mixture models: the importance of considering ecological mechanisms
Ecological Applications, 19 (3): 631--642 (2009)
DOI: 10.1890/07-2107.1
Abstract
Predicting abundance across a species’ distribution is useful for studies of ecology and biodiversity management. Modeling of survey data in relation to environmental variables can be a powerful method for extrapolating abundances across a species’ distribution and, consequently, calculating total abundances and ultimately trends. Research in this area has demonstrated that models of abundance are often unstable and produce spurious estimates, and until recently our ability to remove detection error limited the development of
accurate models. The N-mixture model accounts for detection and abundance simultaneously
and has been a significant advance in abundance modeling. Case studies that have tested these
new models have demonstrated success for some species, but doubt remains over the
appropriateness of standard N-mixture models for many species. Here we develop the Nmixture
model to accommodate zero-inflated data, a common occurrence in ecology, by
employing zero-inflated count models. To our knowledge, this is the first application of this method to modeling count data. We use four variants of the N-mixture model (Poisson, zeroinflated Poisson, negative binomial, and zero-inflated negative binomial) to model abundance, occupancy (zero-inflated models only) and detection probability of six birds in South Australia. We assess models by their statistical fit and the ecological realism of the parameter estimates. Specifically, we assess the statistical fit with AIC and assess the ecological realism by comparing the parameter estimates with expected values derived from literature, ecological
theory, and expert opinion. We demonstrate that, despite being frequently ranked the ‘‘best model’’ according to AIC, the negative binomial variants of the N-mixture often produce ecologically unrealistic parameter estimates. The zero-inflated Poisson variant is preferable to the negative binomial variants of the N-mixture, as it models an ecological mechanism rather than a statistical phenomenon and generates reasonable parameter estimates. Our results emphasize the need to include ecological reasoning when choosing appropriate models and highlight the dangers of modeling statistical properties of the data. We demonstrate that, to obtain ecologically realistic estimates of abundance, occupancy and detection probability, it is essential to understand the sources of variation in the data and then use this information to choose appropriate error distributions.
Key words: AIC; ecological realism; excess
