German capitalism: Does it exist? Can it survive?
MPIfG Discussion Paper, 95/5. Max-Planck-Institut für Gesellschaftsforschung, Köln, (November 1995)Abstract
Drawing on extensive comparison with the United States, Japan and Britain, the paper describes the “German model” of advanced capitalism as an institutionalized high-wage economy combining high competitiveness in world markets with strong social cohesion and, in particular, low levels of inequality along a variety of dimensions. This combination is explained by a unique set of socio-economic institutions, in particular socially instituted and circumscribed markets, negotiated firms commanding long-term attachment of both labor and capital, a facilitating state relying mainly on indirect means of intervention, widespread associational self-governance by organized groups in civil society, and institutionalized cultural patterns that promote long-term commitments and continuity. These institutions are shown to call forth and support a particular pattern of production, sometimes referred to as diversified quality production, that has in the 1970s and 1980s made possible both high wages and a low dispersion of wages and incomes. In its second part, the paper proceeds to analyze in detail the performance problems of an institutionalized high-wage economy of the German kind, and specifies a set of conditions that must be met for such an economy to remain simultaneously competitive and socially cohesive. The present crisis of the German “social market economy” is discussed in terms of a coincidence of three factors: a possible secular exhaustion of the model as such, the shock of unification, and the constraints imposed by growing globalization of the capitalist economy on national economic governance.